Panout review packOverviewFinal memoMVPLive outputsJudge roundsAppendicesDecisions

Live outputs

Captured 2026-09-04 from the founder's machine. Commands run read-only against the installed ledgers.

panout status (panout repo)

Panout status
Contracts installed: 4 (tests-touch, no-secrets, size-guard, agent-attribution)
Evaluations recorded: 8 total, 8 in the last 7 days, 2 for commit(s) no longer on HEAD (amended or reset; kept as recorded)
Exposure: 8/8 commits with a non-skip result (100%; target 30%)
Overrides per contract:
- tests-touch: 2 override(s) over 4 evaluation(s)
- no-secrets: 0 override(s) over 8 evaluation(s)
- size-guard: 4 override(s) over 8 evaluation(s)
- agent-attribution: 0 override(s) over 8 evaluation(s)

panout audit --since 30 (panout repo)

Panout audit · agent-attributed commits · last 30 days
rework column is a line-identity proxy (added lines changed within 30 days), not a defect label
commit       date       harness     override rework30d contracts
66927262d06f 2026-09-04 claude-code no       n/a       tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass
fc6059f85546 2026-09-04 claude-code no       n/a       tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass
1a801e93891f 2026-09-04 claude-code yes      n/a       tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=fail,agent-attribution=pass
07ba44a5d88c 2026-09-04 claude-code no       n/a       tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass
911c75f6f41d 2026-09-04 claude-code yes      n/a       tests-touch=fail,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass
9493548c790d 2026-09-04 claude-code yes      n/a       tests-touch=pass,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=fail,agent-attribution=pass
3f8b9622fa42 2026-08-22 claude-code no       n/a       -

panout inject --commits 12 (dotfiles repo)

Panout inject · 12 accepted commit(s) replayed on a scratch worktree
contract           fault             presented caught   rate
tests-touch        secret-string             2      0     0%
tests-touch        drop-test                 2      2   100%
tests-touch        oversize                  2      0     0%
tests-touch        assertion-delete          5      0     0%
no-secrets         secret-string             2      2   100%
no-secrets         drop-test                 2      0     0%
no-secrets         oversize                  2      0     0%
no-secrets         assertion-delete          5      0     0%
size-guard         secret-string             1      0     0%
size-guard         drop-test                 1      0     0%
size-guard         oversize                  1      1   100%
size-guard         assertion-delete          4      0     0%
agent-attribution  secret-string             2      0     0%
agent-attribution  drop-test                 2      0     0%
agent-attribution  oversize                  2      0     0%
agent-attribution  assertion-delete          5      0     0%
catch rate = injected faults a contract flagged after passing the unfaulted diff; 4 case(s) excluded because the contract already failed at baseline; nothing here grants autonomy yet

Each contract catches exactly the fault it was written for and nothing else. That separation is the point: catch rate is a property of the contract, measured on a chosen sample, with a same-day answer. Cases where the contract already failed on the unfaulted diff are excluded so a contract cannot be credited for a catch it did not make.

panout inject --commits 20 on external repos (gstack, cursor/plugins, openai/codex, obra/superpowers)

== /home/gpj/.explore/repos/github.com/garrytan/gstack
Panout inject · 20 accepted commit(s) replayed on a scratch worktree
contract           fault             presented caught   rate
tests-touch        secret-string            15      0     0%
tests-touch        drop-test                15     15   100%
tests-touch        oversize                 15      0     0%
tests-touch        assertion-delete         19      0     0%
no-secrets         secret-string            15     15   100%
no-secrets         drop-test                15      0     0%
no-secrets         oversize                 15      0     0%
no-secrets         assertion-delete         19      0     0%
size-guard         secret-string             1      0     0%
size-guard         drop-test                 1      0     0%
size-guard         oversize                  1      1   100%
size-guard         assertion-delete          4      0     0%
agent-attribution  secret-string            15      0     0%
agent-attribution  drop-test                15      0     0%
agent-attribution  oversize                 15      0     0%
agent-attribution  assertion-delete         19      0     0%
catch rate = injected faults a contract flagged after passing the unfaulted diff; 57 case(s) excluded because the contract already failed at baseline; nothing here grants autonomy yet
== /home/gpj/.explore/repos/github.com/cursor/plugins
Panout inject · 20 accepted commit(s) replayed on a scratch worktree
contract           fault             presented caught   rate
tests-touch        secret-string             0      0    n/a
tests-touch        drop-test                 0      0    n/a
tests-touch        oversize                  0      0    n/a
tests-touch        assertion-delete          0      0    n/a
no-secrets         secret-string             0      0    n/a
no-secrets         drop-test                 0      0    n/a
no-secrets         oversize                  0      0    n/a
no-secrets         assertion-delete          0      0    n/a
size-guard         secret-string             0      0    n/a
size-guard         drop-test                 0      0    n/a
size-guard         oversize                  0      0    n/a
size-guard         assertion-delete          0      0    n/a
agent-attribution  secret-string             0      0    n/a
agent-attribution  drop-test                 0      0    n/a
agent-attribution  oversize                  0      0    n/a
agent-attribution  assertion-delete          0      0    n/a
catch rate = injected faults a contract flagged after passing the unfaulted diff; 0 case(s) excluded because the contract already failed at baseline; nothing here grants autonomy yet
== /home/gpj/.explore/repos/github.com/openai/codex
Panout inject · 20 accepted commit(s) replayed on a scratch worktree
contract           fault             presented caught   rate
tests-touch        secret-string            14      0     0%
tests-touch        drop-test                14     14   100%
tests-touch        oversize                 14      0     0%
tests-touch        assertion-delete         18      0     0%
no-secrets         secret-string            16     16   100%
no-secrets         drop-test                14      0     0%
no-secrets         oversize                 16      0     0%
no-secrets         assertion-delete         18      0     0%
size-guard         secret-string             5      0     0%
size-guard         drop-test                 3      0     0%
size-guard         oversize                  5      5   100%
size-guard         assertion-delete          7      0     0%
agent-attribution  secret-string            16      0     0%
agent-attribution  drop-test                14      0     0%
agent-attribution  oversize                 16      0     0%
agent-attribution  assertion-delete         18      0     0%
catch rate = injected faults a contract flagged after passing the unfaulted diff; 48 case(s) excluded because the contract already failed at baseline; nothing here grants autonomy yet
== /home/gpj/.explore/repos/github.com/obra/superpowers
Panout inject · 20 accepted commit(s) replayed on a scratch worktree
contract           fault             presented caught   rate
tests-touch        secret-string             2      0     0%
tests-touch        drop-test                 2      2   100%
tests-touch        oversize                  2      0     0%
tests-touch        assertion-delete          4      0     0%
no-secrets         secret-string             9      9   100%
no-secrets         drop-test                 2      0     0%
no-secrets         oversize                  9      0     0%
no-secrets         assertion-delete          4      0     0%
size-guard         secret-string             7      0     0%
size-guard         drop-test                 0      0    n/a
size-guard         oversize                  7      7   100%
size-guard         assertion-delete          2      0     0%
agent-attribution  secret-string             9      0     0%
agent-attribution  drop-test                 2      0     0%
agent-attribution  oversize                  9      0     0%
agent-attribution  assertion-delete          4      0     0%
catch rate = injected faults a contract flagged after passing the unfaulted diff; 22 case(s) excluded because the contract already failed at baseline; nothing here grants autonomy yet

Commit trailers on HEAD

66927262 2026-09-04 Round 6 judgment: 61/100 on appendices I, J, K
Panout-Work: 0675a1148d
Panout-Contracts: tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass

fc6059f8 2026-09-04 Appendix K: market and incumbent update; narrow the override-record claim
Panout-Work: 936c21667b
Panout-Contracts: tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass

1a801e93 2026-09-04 Appendices I and J: retrospective contract backtest, external repos, fault injection
Panout-Work: 08f6edcba6
Panout-Contracts: tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=fail,agent-attribution=pass

07ba44a5 2026-09-04 DECISIONS: ledger keeps evaluations for amended or reset commits
Panout-Work: 23cb4dce38
Panout-Contracts: tests-touch=skip,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass

911c75f6 2026-09-04 inject: credit a catch only when the contract passed the unfaulted diff
Panout-Work: 713a47945f
Panout-Contracts: tests-touch=fail,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=pass,agent-attribution=pass

9493548c 2026-09-04 Panout MVP: contracts, commit hooks, evaluation capture, status, audit, inject
Panout-Work: 1ee4e892c4
Panout-Contracts: tests-touch=pass,no-secrets=pass,size-guard=fail,agent-attribution=pass

c1a28dcf 2026-08-23 Archive Panout prototype and design research

Two of the three MVP commits carry an override: the MVP commit shipped past size-guard, and the inject fix shipped past tests-touch. Both are recorded in the trailer and the ledger, and both are true.

Test run

.....................
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ran 21 tests in 2.264s

OK